SOC 1 vs SOC 2: which report do you need?

Key takeaways

  • SOC 1 covers controls relevant to customers' financial reporting, while SOC 2 covers security and other Trust Services Criteria, and neither is a higher version.
  • The five SOC 2 categories are security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy, and only security is common to all engagements.
  • A Type 1 report assesses control design at a specified date, while Type 2 adds testing of operating effectiveness across a period.
  • SOC 3 covers the same subject matter as SOC 2 with less detail and can be freely distributed, but it lacks detailed test results.

Choose SOC 1 when customers need assurance about controls relevant to their financial reporting; choose SOC 2 when they need assurance about controls supporting security and other applicable Trust Services Criteria. Some organizations need both because the reports answer different questions. This guide explains their scope, reporting types, and practical selection criteria so you can match the report to the request. (us.aicpa.org)

What is the difference between SOC 1 and SOC 2?

The main difference is purpose: SOC 1 examines controls relevant to customers’ internal control over financial reporting, while SOC 2 examines controls relevant to security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, or privacy. Neither is a higher version of the other. They address different assurance needs within the AICPA’s System and Organization Controls reporting framework. (us.aicpa.org)

Think of the SOC 1 vs SOC 2 report decision as two separate questions: “Could our service affect a customer’s financial statements?” and “How do we protect and operate the systems customers rely on?” Your answers may point to one report or both. (us.aicpa.org)

Comparison SOC 1 SOC 2
Primary focus Controls relevant to customer financial reporting Controls evaluated against applicable Trust Services Criteria
Typical readers Customer finance teams and financial statement auditors Customer security, risk, and compliance teams
Evaluation basis Relevant control objectives and related controls Applicable AICPA Trust Services Criteria
Reporting options Type 1 or Type 2 Type 1 or Type 2

These distinctions determine what an auditor evaluates and what a customer can learn from the report. Confirm the requester’s intended use before selecting an engagement. (us.aicpa.org)

SOC 1: assurance for financial reporting

SOC 1 is relevant when an outsourced service affects the information or processes customers use in financial reporting. Its scope concerns the service organization’s controls—not an audit of the customer’s financial statements or a blanket assessment of every business activity. The connection to customer financial reporting is what matters. (us.aicpa.org)

Consider a hypothetical payroll processor. Customers might depend on its calculations and transaction processing when recording payroll expenses and liabilities. A SOC 1 examination could address relevant control objectives around those activities, with the precise scope determined by the service and its financial-reporting implications. (us.aicpa.org)

A useful scoping exercise is to identify the information customers receive, trace where it enters their accounting processes, and discuss the associated risks with their auditors. Do not assume that handling payments automatically makes every service or system relevant. Start with the financial-reporting dependency, then define the controls needed to address it. (us.aicpa.org)

SOC 2: assurance for systems and information

SOC 2 evaluates controls against the applicable AICPA Trust Services Criteria. What buyers often call “SOC 2 standards” is not a universal checklist of identical technologies or policies. The criteria provide the evaluation framework; the controls must fit the organization’s services, risks, and commitments. (aicpa-cima.com)

The five Trust Services categories

Security provides the common criteria used in SOC 2 engagements. Additional categories should reflect relevant services and commitments rather than a desire to include everything. (crowe.com)

  • Security: Protecting information and systems against unauthorized access, disclosure, and damage.
  • Availability: Making systems available for operation and use to meet objectives.
  • Processing integrity: Supporting complete, valid, accurate, timely, and authorized processing.
  • Confidentiality: Protecting information designated as confidential.
  • Privacy: Addressing how personal information is collected, used, retained, disclosed, and disposed of. (us.aicpa.org)

For example, a hypothetical hosting provider with service-availability commitments should discuss whether availability belongs in scope. A provider handling sensitive business documents should consider confidentiality. These are scoping prompts, not automatic rules based on an industry label. (us.aicpa.org)

SOC 2 requirements in practice

SOC 2 requirements include describing the system and establishing controls that address the applicable criteria. The system description matters because readers need to understand what the examination covers. A report covering one service should not be treated as assurance over unrelated products or operations. (aicpa-cima.com)

As preparation, map each applicable criterion to a control, an accountable owner, and supporting evidence. Discuss possible evidence—such as access reviews, approved changes, or incident records—with the examining CPA firm rather than assuming a software tool’s checklist defines the engagement. Only a licensed CPA firm can issue a valid SOC 2 report. (us.aicpa.org)

How do Type 1 and Type 2 reports differ?

Type 1 addresses the system description and suitability of control design as of a specified date. Type 2 adds an assessment of operating effectiveness throughout a specified period, including descriptions of the auditor’s tests and their results. This distinction applies to both SOC 1 and SOC 2. (content.naic.org)

The SOC 2 Type 1 vs Type 2 choice therefore concerns time and evidence—not different Trust Services categories. A Type 1 report does not provide the operating-effectiveness opinion included in Type 2. If a customer needs evidence that controls operated over time, confirm whether anything short of Type 2 will meet its request. (us.aicpa.org)

For SOC 1 Type 2 vs SOC 2, separate the two decisions. “SOC 1” identifies the financial-reporting subject matter; “Type 2” identifies the assessment of operating effectiveness over a period. A SOC 1 Type 2 report does not become a substitute for SOC 2 merely because it includes control testing. (us.aicpa.org)

SOC 1 vs SOC 2 vs SOC 3

SOC 3 addresses the same broad Trust Services subject matter as SOC 2 but provides less detail and is intended for general use. Unlike a detailed SOC 2 report, a SOC 3 report can be freely distributed. It can therefore serve a public-facing assurance purpose without providing the same depth of information. (aicpa-cima.com)

The practical distinction is audience and intended use:

  • SOC 1: Financial-reporting assurance for relevant customers and their auditors.
  • SOC 2: Detailed information for users evaluating relevant system controls.
  • SOC 3: General-use reporting suitable for broader distribution. (us.aicpa.org)

If a prospect requests detailed testing information, do not assume SOC 3 will satisfy that request. Ask whether it needs public-facing assurance or evidence for a substantive vendor review. SOC 3 does not include the detailed descriptions of control tests and results found in a SOC 2 Type 2 report. (us.aicpa.org)

Which report fits your customer’s request?

Choose the report by identifying the customer’s assurance objective, then confirming the necessary scope and reporting type. Financial-reporting reliance points toward SOC 1; system-security and related operational assurance point toward SOC 2. If both needs exist, evaluate both reports rather than trying to stretch one beyond its purpose. (us.aicpa.org)

Use these questions before commissioning an examination:

  1. Who requested it? Ask whether the request supports a financial statement audit, vendor-risk review, or another purpose.
  2. Which service matters? Identify the exact product, system, process, and relevant locations.
  3. What must be covered? Confirm financial-reporting control objectives or applicable Trust Services categories.
  4. What evidence is expected? Establish whether a point-in-time assessment is sufficient or operating effectiveness is required.
  5. Which dates matter? Align the proposed report date or period with the recipient’s needs. (assets.ctfassets.net)

Read beyond the report label

When reviewing a vendor’s report, inspect the covered system, reporting dates, auditor’s opinion, and relevant findings. Also review complementary user entity controls: these identify controls the service organization assumes customers will implement. Possessing a report is not the same as confirming that it addresses your particular outsourcing risk. (assets.ctfassets.net)

Before choosing your own engagement, write a short scope statement covering the service, intended readers, assurance objective, report type, and timing. Use it to resolve ambiguities with customers and the examining CPA firm. The right report is the one that answers the recipient’s actual question—not the one with the highest number. (aicpa-cima.com)

Sources

  1. Questions and Answers About The AICPA Peer Review Program | Resources | AICPA & CIMA
  2. Accounting & Financial Reporting | Resources | AICPA & CIMA
  3. 2017 Trust Services Criteria (With Revised Points of Focus – 2022) | Resources | AICPA & CIMA
  4. crowe.com: Upgrading and refining your soc 2 report faq
  5. Accounting & Financial Reporting | Resources | AICPA & CIMA
  6. 2018 SOC 2® Description Criteria (With Revised Implementation Guidance – 2022) | Resources | AICPA & CIMA
  7. content.naic.org: Att%20A Combined
  8. SOC 3® - SOC for Service Organizations: Trust Services Criteria for General Use Report | AICPA & CIMA
  9. assets.ctfassets.net: SOC 2 Report %C3%82 Review Checklist
  10. System and Organization Controls: SOC Suite of Services | Resources | AICPA & CIMA